Valentine's Day Egg in a Hole Toasts

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Adorable and ridiculously easy, these Valentine's Day Egg in a Hole Toasts are perfect for a Valentine's Day breakfast or brunch or to show you love someone any day of the year.

Valentine's Day is approaching, and while I don't always love the forced celebration of love, I am a sucker for celebrating any and all holidays (including the made-up, Hallmark ones) with my kiddos. You should have seen their faces when I cut hearts out of their regular bread to make these Valentine's egg in a hole toasts and then made them heart-shaped peanut butter and jelly sandwiches later in the day. It was like I had saved the world from the perils of global warming. All was right with their world, and, hence, all was right with mine.

these valentine's egg in a hole toasts are the simplest, most delicious breakfast or brunch to make.

Whether you're celebrating Valentine's, Galentine's or whatever, it's a great excuse to make some specialty foods to celebrate the people you love. It's also the easiest thing to make ever -- taking about 10 minutes total to make. Most all of that time is them baking in the oven...so there's not even hands-on time making these in a frying pan.

The one tool you need (kinda)

You will need a heart shaped cookie cutter, but this time of year you can always find them in Target or a craft store. I also use the small heart shapes for cutting potatoes, fruit, you name it. If it's cuttable, I love cutting the kids' food with it during the holidays. You could always do this without one if you're highly skilled, but I'm not, so I buy a cheap cookie cutter that'll last me for the next 50 years of egg toasts.

Depending on the thickness of your bread, you may have to pick up the bread with the cookie cutter and poke the cookie cutter through the bread so it cuts nicely. Don't be afraid to get handsy with it.

heart cookie cutter with hearts cut out of the toasts. Egg is in a bowl waiting to be poured into the toasts.

Tips for making these Valentine's Egg in a Hole Toasts

Look, these toasts aren't rocket science here, but there are a couple of things that are worth noting:

Don't forget to butter the toast. This'll prevent the bread for burning and will instead make sure it's a nice golden brown when it comes out of the oven.
Crack the eggs one at a time into another bowl first. By doing this one at a time, you can make sure your yolk is still whole, which is essential. You want the yolk to keep it's shape instead of being a messy pile of yolk. THEN gently pour the entire egg from the bowl into the hole of the bread.
Don't worry if a little egg white escapes. A little egg white will inevitably run out of the bottom a tiny bit, but it won't mess up anything.
Lessen cook time or increase cook time. Depending on how runny you like your eggs, decrease or increase the bake time. I like mine pretty runny, so 8-10 minutes is perfect for me. If you want yours more cooked like my kids like it, you'll want to do more like 12 minutes.
Feel free to jazz up the egg toasts once they come out. Consider jazzing them up with cayenne pepper to give them an extra kick, salsa, chimichurri, or some smashed avocado. All would be amazing accompaniments.

toasts are buttered before the eggs go in the hole to be baked.

Eliminate food waste - save the scraps!

Don't waste them! The "scraps" of these toasts are these adorable hearts. Make them into french toast. If you're not going to make the French toast that same day, be sure to save them in an airtight container until the next day. These are great because you can get two hearts from one piece of bread.

valentine's day eggs in a hole with strawberries on-parchment paper

Other Breakfast or Brunch Ideas

If you're hosting a large crew for breakfast or brunch, here are some other ideas to serve with the toasts:

Our favorite pancakes are the kids' favorite -- and paired with a simple blueberry maple syrup -- yes please!
Waffles are also a huge hit -- especially with a Nutella whipped cream
Blueberry Breakfast Cake is the best way to not feel guilty about eating cake for breakfast.
This Healthy Egg and Vegetable Breakfast Bake is great to make in advance
Love this Crescent Roll Breakfast Ring. You could always use red and pink vegetables to make it Valentine's Day festive.
These Easy Banana Bread Muffins are divine.

As always, if you make anything from the blog, be sure to let me know! I love hearing from you in the comments on this post below or find Worn Slap Out on Facebook, Instagram, or Pinterest!